Gutter Guards Reviews: How Should You Decide The Best  Gutter Guards at Home Install?

This guide is designed to give you a brief overview of gutter protection to assist you in the decision-making process. With so many types of best gutter guards systems on the market, it’s crucial to homeowners understand the pros and cons of each. This gutter guards reviews guide will clear up any question or misconception you may have about specific types of gutter protection. When making your decision to buy gutter guards, consider the reputation of the manufacturer, the quality and reliability of the product’s performance, the product’s warranty and whether the product has been independently tested and certified.You can check these article to review the best gutter guards protection 2018.

Best Gutter Guard 2018

CategoryComapnyRatingShop Gutter Guards
Best Mesh Gutter GuardsA-M Gutter Guard4.9Check Current Price
Second Best Mesh Gutter GuardsLeafsOut4.3Check Current Price
Mesh Gutter Guards
E-Z-GUTTER GUARD4.5Check Current Price
Mesh Gutter Guards
4Check Current Price
Best Sponge/foamsGutterStuff3Check Current Price
Best Gutter Brush insertsGutterBrush LLC4.5Check Current Price
Best Aluminum Gutter GuardsFlexxPoint4.5Check Current Price
Best Metal ScreensEasyOn4Check Current Price
Best Plastic screensAmerimax 4Check Current Price
Best Installation Company Leaf Filter
Leaf Filter
4.5Get Free Estimate

best gutter guards reviews

Image Credit:

Why Do We Need Best Gutter Guards in First Place?

If you live in an area that receives a lot of rain, then it becomes essential that you take all measures to protect your home from the onslaught of moisture. If rainwater accumulates on your roof, it may cause damage to not only the roof but also to the walls through which it may seep into various parts of the house. Heavy rains lead the soil around your home to get saturated with moisture. Gutter guards reviews state that this could affect the very foundation of the building, the basement, the walls and may cause extensive damage to your home that might cost a fortune in getting it repaired.

The situation becomes all the graver as the moisture-laden soil will lead to the excess of moisture in the air inside your home which in turn condenses on various surfaces of your home. It may further cause the development of mold in your home on the walls, ceilings and even on the exterior walls of your home. The accumulation of moisture may result in silent rotting of the wood in your attic and other parts and that may be a really expensive affair. This is the reason that in such areas you need to get the gutters installed in your home.

But many a tie, it has been seen that the homes that have a guttering system installed in their home also tend to suffer from moisture damage. Well, that is not because you are ought to suffer damage from moisture but because probably your guttering system failed. Yes, the Best gutter guards can fail too and there are several reasons for that.

The Reasons Behind the Failure of Gutters

Most of the people do not understand the importance of a properly functioning gutter system. This is true that cleaning or taking care of gutters is not a very exciting thing to do but after all a few things needs to be done anyway. However, there a few important reasons why the gutters fail

Sheer Neglect of Your Guttering System

Whether you agree or not neglecting this very important system of your home is the sole cause of failure of the gutters installed in your home most of the time. Since the gutters are installed in open there is a high probability of various types of things enters the system. There could be leaves lodged in the gutter or the gutter could get blocked due to the accumulation of mere dust in large quantities. According to Gutter guards reviews many a time there could be the growth of plants in it due to washing down of the small seeds that may have fallen on the roof of your home. This makes it imperative that regular and thorough cleaning of your guttering is done.

Deterioration Due to Corrosion Or Rust

Your guttering system may get deteriorated due to the effect of moisture that may cause the corrosion of the pipes used in the guttering system. This is mostly with the systems that use steel pipes. Since steel is cheaper than any other material and has great strength, it is more prone to corrosion and rusting. To keep the steel guttering from rusting or other kinds of corrosion you must keep it clean and free from debris of all kinds. This will not let water to get retained in the system and this will prevent corrosion for long. However, if you use other materials for your gutter like the aluminum gutter guard, it will be better able to withstand corrosion.

Gutter Spikes

Many people tend to use gutter spikes to install the guttering system. But, the problem with these spikes is that they may become loose over time. If they are not checked on a regular basis your whole guttering system may fall off. So, make sure that you install them at an interval of one to five years time so that you do not have to pay heavy gutter installation cost.

Clogging Gutters

This is one factor that is one of the main causes of gutter failure. The gutters that are clogged will never be able to drain the rainwater effectively. If you carry out regular checkups of the guttering system you can escape the problem of the clogged drains. The clogging may take place either due to collect debris or due to the growth of the roots of surrounding trees in the guttering system. Also, the gutter guard reviews suggest that the debris may decay over time leading to the production an acidic environment that adds to the corrosion of the pipes. You must check regularly for this problem and sort it out before it actually harms your pocket.

Natural Stress and Strain

The weather does no remain the same throughout the year and this also leads to a lot of temperature variation that leads to the formation of stress and strains in the material of the guttering system. This may cause the drains to crack or become weak. When the gutters remain clogged water may get accumulated. This may get frozen during the winters and may exert pressure on the walls of the gutter. This is one of the reasons for the development of cracks and therefore the failure of your guttering system.

Do You Suffer From a Gutter Problem? Try These Two Simple Tests

Due to its sneaky nature, water is a dangerous entity. Generally, gutters are installed to direct water away from the foundation of the homes because this is one area of your home where water can play havoc. Water has the potential to erode the soil that supports the foundation of your home. Also, it may combine chemically with certain portions of the soil to create acidity that will further damage the foundation. If you have leaky gutters, according to gutter guard reviews, your home’s foundation may be in danger so it becomes important that you test your gutters for any leaks present. For this, there are tests such as



  • Look at your sidings and landscaping for the evidence of splashing

For this kind of test, you will need two things

  • A ladder
  • A hosepipe

The ladder will be needed to reach the top of the gutter that is on the roof. Now turn the hosepipe on and push it in the gutter. Now you have to check around your house for any signs of leakage of water from the gutter into the soil. Where there is dark you must also carry with yourself a torch to complete the process. Any areas that show the leakage must be repaired at the earliest.

  • Look at your gutters for dirt residue

When dirt accumulates over a period of time it tends to create blockage in the pipe-way. This blockage may become so severe that it may not allow the rainwater to pass through it completely. Also, dirt may act like manure for small seeds that may germinate and grow into plants inside the guttering system causing it considerable damage. All this needs to be checked on a regular basis and an inspection needs to be carried out to keep your gutters free-flowing.

The steps to prevention of this blockage

If you want to have a hassle-free life without bothering much about the cleaning and inspection of the guttering system then you must make sure that you provide enough protection to your gutters with the help of gutter guards.

Types of Best Gutter Guard Systems

There are various types of best gutter guards available in the market. Some are such that can be installed by anyone, even a simple homeowner. While for the others will need you to hire the professionals to carry out the installation process.

The home Owner Installed Systems

There are many types of systems that can be installed by the homeowners such as

Metal Screens:

These easy to install screens are easily available and are made of steel or it may be aluminum gutter guard. They can be installed on the top of your gutters that are already present. They can prevent large leaves from entering the gutter but they cannot prevent finer particles from entering the gutter. Also it is a little difficult when the clutter gets collected in the small hole left by the screen. For this you may have to regularly clean the gutter.

Advantages of Metal Screen Gutter Guard.
  • Inexpensive

The metal screens are cheaper as compared to the other options available in the market.

  • Proper fit

The metal screens can be cut to fit and therefore provide protection for all sides


 Disadvantages of Metal Screen Gutter Guard.
  • The design

The concave structure can lead to the build of leaves and it can lead to clogging

  • Cumbersome cleaning

The cleaning of the gutters is cumbersome as you will need to remove the mesh and hoe it down, hose down the whole gutter and then replace the mesh.



you just need to place this special sponge material in your gutter. This allows water to drip through the sponge but the debris remains outside. But this material is readily inflammable and since the debris and leaves may remain stuck to it for long it may give rise to mold and compost. This can be used as a short-term measure for keeping your drains protected.

Advantages of sponge foam
  • Simple and easy to install

The method is simple and does not require much effort for installation. You just need to place the foam in position.

Disadvantages of sponge foam
  • Not long lasting

Since the gutters remain in open under the direct sun the foam shows deterioration in just in a matter of 1 to 2 years.

  • Can get clogged easily

The top of the gutter may get clogged with leaves and may need bushing at regular intervals.

The dust particles can get through the finer pores of the foam and may clog the gutter anyway.

  • Fungal growth

This may lead to the growth of fungus and other organic growth.

Brush inserts/ pipe cleaner:

this is something like a bottle brush. The spikes that protrude from the wire helps keep the gutter clean. But, finer debris and dirt may still get caught and may cause the blockage of the gutter. Also, they are not so easy to maintain

Advantages of brush inserts
  • Easy to clean

Since it is like brush just moving the brush may clean the debris off the gutter.

Disadvantages of brush insert
  • Clogging

The bigger leaves may eventually (when they shrivel up) may get lodged into the gutter and may cause the problem of clogging.

  • Cleaning hassles

You will need to devote a good amount of time cleaning the brush.

Plastic screens:

these are almost like metal screens and have the advantage that they can be slid into place. But they may allow smaller debris into the gutter beating the purpose.

Advantages of Plastic Screens
  • Easy to clean

They are easy to clean as you can easily slide them out

  • Long lasting

The plastic screens are long-lasting because they do not corrode like metal due to the action of water

Disadvantages of plastic screens
  • Limited life

Though they do not corrode in water but plastic cannot tolerate sun well. This is the reason that they may not last as long.

  • Clogging

Though the larger leaves are prevented from entering the system but they do accumulated over the screen. Moreover, the smaller debris may still enter the gutter through the screen and clogging could still be a problem.


this allows only the rainwater to enter the hole or slit while the debris is washed off the edge of the roof. This type may also get readily clogged and you may need to clean it regularly.

Advantages of slit
  • Prevents the larger debris

The slit or hole helps you keep larger debris out f gutter allowing only water to enter the gutter

Disadvantages of slit
  • Clogging

Since there is just a sit or hole for the water to pass through it may get obstructed by leaves.

  • Needs regular cleaning

You will have to keep looking for the signs of clogging and keep cleaning the area to prevent water falling from over the edge.

Homeowner Solutions Summary

The products that can be installed by the homeowners are definitely less expensive than the ones that need professional installations. According to gutter guard reviews, they are convenient to purchase and bring home. The problems associated with the homeowner installed guttering systems are many. You will need to take all the pains of installation, there may or may not be a warranty available; may not be as durable and may require being replaced after a very short time; may not be able to keep all kinds of debris out and you may need to clean it manually.


Professionally installed gutter guard systems

The types of professionally installed system available in the market are


Whether this slit or hole system is homeowner installed or is professionally installed the problems remain the same. Also, this system has limited guaranty as far as clogging is concerned.

Advantages of slit
  • Prevents larger debris from entering the gutter

If you have a lot of trees around your home you can rest assured that no leaf can enter the gutter system if it is protected by this method.

Disadvantages of slit
  • Clogging

Since the opening for water flow is very thin there is a fair chance that it may get covered by the leaves and water may fall off the edge.

  • Regular cleaning required

You will have to keep the slit clean on a regular basis.

Reverse curve:

until the year 2005, the reverse curve type of gutter protectors was the most widely accepted and used protection systems. The logic was that the reverse curve will allow the rainwater to flow to the front of the gutter while debris would be pushed off the front edge. But, this may be attractive to the bees and other pests. Also, bigger leaves and pine needles may cause the blockage. Also, the installation is typical and may cause some problems with the roof warranty.

Advantages of reverse curve
  • No clogging

The gutters remain unclogged due to open design

Disadvantages of reverse curve
  • May lead to pests

Pests may enter the gutter system due to the open design. There could be hives too.

  • Clogging

Larger items too may flow into the gutter and cause the problem of clogging

Micromesh gutter guards:

as the name suggests, this system consists of a mesh that has very fine pores that only allow the rainwater to pass through it. Even the sand particles do not pass through this kind of protector and this is what prevents the gutter from clogging. The main thing that you must look for while installing the Micromesh gutter guards is the angle. Two steep angle may not hold all of the water and too less an angle may just help the mesh in trapping water for long. These are best as far as gutter protection is concerned.

Advantages of micromesh
  • Completely sealed

The complete sealing leads to no allowance of leaves and larger debris into the gutters. Even the smaller debris is prevented from entering the gutter system.

  • No organic growth

If you use the surgical grade steel for the purpose you will have no problem with any organic growth under it.

  • Long lasting

This system will leave you tension free for years together.

Disadvantages of micromesh
  • Price

This is comparatively little bit expensive than others.

  • Industry Reputation

You need to choose carefully the right company.

Professionally installed systems summary

The professionally installed gutter guards are though expensive and need you to hire professionals for the installation but they are based on the more advanced technology and are efficient enough to keep out most of the debris. This will require you to carry out only take some minor care of the system. But, since there are so many best gutter guards in the market that it becomes very difficult to make a choice. Also, you must choose these gutter protectors with care so that your roof warranty is not infringed upon.

Understanding Warranties/Guarantees

Generally, the professionally installed systems come with warranties but you must just not buy the system because it says that there is warranty. You must inquire about these points regarding the warranty of the protector systems

  • The duration of the coverage that is provided by the warranty.
  • The transferability of the warranty
  • The services guaranteed under the guarantee period.
  • The actions or things that may void the warranty
  • Does the warranty also include cleaning the gutters if there is clogging

Top Questions to Ask When Selecting Best Gutter Guards

Question 1: what will be the estimate for the complete protection of your guttering system? The time period for which the seller or manufacturer honors estimate

Question 2: what warranty is given to the product? What are the features that are covered? Will the warranty be transferable?

Question3: how much sealing does the system provide? Does it come with any holes or openings of any kinds?

Question 4: in what ways do you train your installers? What are the quality control criteria?

Question 5: will there be any impact of the installation of gutter protection system on my roof?

Question 6: what is the type of maintenance that the homeowner needs to do?

Question 7: what are the contact details in case I need your assistance? In how much time do you respond?

Question 8: how much rainwater can be handled by these gutter protectors?

Question 9: how long have you been in the business of installation of the gutter guard systems?

Question 10: can you give me some references that would help me make a decision?

Leave a Comment